Country-Level Effectiveness and Accountability Review : Madagascar
This Country-Level Effectiveness and Accountability Review (CLEAR) examines the efficacy of microfinance aid in Madagascar, based on an objective analysis of donor assistance for the sustainable development of financial systems targeting the poor....
| Main Authors: | , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Working Paper |
| Language: | English en_US |
| Published: |
CGAP and the World Bank, Washington, DC
2014
|
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2005/10/18626355/country-level-effectiveness-accountability-review-clear-madagascar http://hdl.handle.net/10986/16961 |
| id |
okr-10986-16961 |
|---|---|
| recordtype |
oai_dc |
| repository_type |
Digital Repository |
| institution_category |
Foreign Institution |
| institution |
Digital Repositories |
| building |
World Bank Open Knowledge Repository |
| collection |
World Bank |
| language |
English en_US |
| topic |
ACCESS TO FINANCIAL SERVICES ACCESS TO TRAINING ACCOUNTING ADVOCACY ACTIVITIES AGRICULTURAL BANK AGRICULTURAL FINANCE AGRICULTURAL PRODUCT AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTS AID EFFECTIVENESS APEX INSTITUTIONS ARREARS AUCTION BALANCE SHEETS BANK BRANCHES BANK RATES BANKING LAW BANKING NETWORK BANKING REGULATIONS BANKING SECTOR BANKING SECTORS BANKING SUPERVISION BANKING SYSTEM BORROWING BUSINESS PLAN BUSINESS PLANS CAPACITY BUILDING CAPITAL MARKET CASH FLOWS CENTRAL BANK CHECKING ACCOUNTS COLLATERAL COLLECTIVE ACTION COMMERCIAL BANK COMMERCIAL BANKS COMPETITIVE BIDDING COOPERATIVE BANKS COOPERATIVES CORRUPTION COST OF CREDIT CREDIT AGENCY CREDIT ASSOCIATION CREDIT BANKS CREDIT BUREAUS CREDIT INFORMATION CREDIT INFORMATION BUREAU CREDIT SUPPORT CUSTOMER BASE DEBT DEEDS DEMAND FOR CREDIT DEPOSITS DEVALUATION DEVELOPING COUNTRIES DEVELOPMENT BANK DISCLOSURE GUIDELINES DIVERSIFICATION DONOR FUNDING DONOR FUNDS DONOR SUBSIDIES DONOR SUPPORT ECONOMIC COOPERATION ECONOMIC CRISES ECONOMIC CRISIS ECONOMIC GROWTH EDUCATION SYSTEM ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA ENTERPRISE PROMOTION EQUIPMENT EXCHANGE RATE EXTERNAL DEBT EXTERNAL FINANCING EXTERNAL SHOCKS FARMERS FINANCE COMPANIES FINANCES FINANCIAL COSTS FINANCIAL HEALTH FINANCIAL INFORMATION FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS FINANCIAL MARKET FINANCIAL MARKETS FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE FINANCIAL RESOURCES FINANCIAL SECTOR ASSESSMENT FINANCIAL SECTOR DEVELOPMENTS FINANCIAL SECTOR REFORM FINANCIAL SERVICE FINANCIAL SERVICES FINANCIAL SERVICES PROVIDERS FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FINANCIAL STRUCTURE FINANCIAL SUPPORT FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY FINANCIAL SYSTEM FINANCIAL SYSTEMS FINANCIAL TOOL FINANCIAL TOOLS FINANCIAL TRAINING FINANCIAL VIABILITY FINANCING FACILITIES FOREIGN EXCHANGE FORMAL FINANCIAL SECTOR GUARANTEE FUND GUARANTEE FUNDS HUMAN RESOURCES ILLITERACY INCOME TAX INFLATION INFLATION RATE INFORMATION SHARING INFORMATION SYSTEM INFORMATION SYSTEMS INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENTS INSURANCE INSURANCE COMPANIES INTEREST INCOME INTEREST RATE INTEREST RATE POLICY INTEREST RATES INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT INTERNATIONAL INVESTORS INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS INVENTORY INVESTMENT RISK JOINT STOCK COMPANIES LACK OF INFORMATION LACK OF KNOWLEDGE LAND RECORDS LEGAL FRAMEWORK LEGAL SYSTEM LINES OF CREDIT LOAN LOAN COOPERATIVES LOAN CUSTOMERS LOAN DEFAULTS LOAN PORTFOLIO LOAN PORTFOLIOS LOAN REPAYMENT LOAN VOLUME LOCAL BANKS LOCAL CURRENCY LOCAL FINANCIAL MARKETS LONG-TERM INVESTMENTS LONG-TERM LOANS MACROECONOMIC STABILITY MACROECONOMIC STABILIZATION MARKET DISTORTIONS MARKET ECONOMY MERCHANT MERCHANTS MFI MFIS MICROCREDIT MICROFINANCE MICROFINANCE INSTITUTIONS MICROFINANCE SECTOR MONETARY FUND MONEYLENDERS MORTGAGES NATIONAL BANK NATIONAL BANKS OPERATING COSTS OUTREACH OUTSTANDING CREDIT OUTSTANDING LOANS PAYMENT HISTORY PENETRATION RATE POOR CLIENTS PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT PORTFOLIO QUALITY POST OFFICES POSTAL SAVINGS POTENTIAL INVESTORS PRIVATE CAPITAL PRIVATE INVESTORS PROFITABILITY PROVISIONING RULES REGISTRATION FEES REGULATORY FRAMEWORK REPAYMENTS RESERVES RETURN RETURN ON ASSETS RETURNS RISK MANAGEMENT RISK OF DEFAULT RURAL CREDIT RURAL FINANCE SAVINGS SAVINGS ACCOUNTS SAVINGS BANK SAVINGS BANKS SCHOLARSHIPS SHAREHOLDER SHAREHOLDERS SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT SUBSIDIZATION SUPERVISORY AUTHORITY SUPPLY OF CREDIT TAX EXEMPTIONS TAX PROVISIONS TAX SYSTEM TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE TECHNICAL SUPPORT TELECOMMUNICATIONS TERM CREDIT TRAINING CENTER TRANSACTION TRANSACTION COSTS TRANSPARENCY TREASURY TREASURY BILL TREASURY BILL RATE TREASURY BILLS TURNOVER UNFAIR COMPETITION UNION UNIONS VILLAGE |
| spellingShingle |
ACCESS TO FINANCIAL SERVICES ACCESS TO TRAINING ACCOUNTING ADVOCACY ACTIVITIES AGRICULTURAL BANK AGRICULTURAL FINANCE AGRICULTURAL PRODUCT AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTS AID EFFECTIVENESS APEX INSTITUTIONS ARREARS AUCTION BALANCE SHEETS BANK BRANCHES BANK RATES BANKING LAW BANKING NETWORK BANKING REGULATIONS BANKING SECTOR BANKING SECTORS BANKING SUPERVISION BANKING SYSTEM BORROWING BUSINESS PLAN BUSINESS PLANS CAPACITY BUILDING CAPITAL MARKET CASH FLOWS CENTRAL BANK CHECKING ACCOUNTS COLLATERAL COLLECTIVE ACTION COMMERCIAL BANK COMMERCIAL BANKS COMPETITIVE BIDDING COOPERATIVE BANKS COOPERATIVES CORRUPTION COST OF CREDIT CREDIT AGENCY CREDIT ASSOCIATION CREDIT BANKS CREDIT BUREAUS CREDIT INFORMATION CREDIT INFORMATION BUREAU CREDIT SUPPORT CUSTOMER BASE DEBT DEEDS DEMAND FOR CREDIT DEPOSITS DEVALUATION DEVELOPING COUNTRIES DEVELOPMENT BANK DISCLOSURE GUIDELINES DIVERSIFICATION DONOR FUNDING DONOR FUNDS DONOR SUBSIDIES DONOR SUPPORT ECONOMIC COOPERATION ECONOMIC CRISES ECONOMIC CRISIS ECONOMIC GROWTH EDUCATION SYSTEM ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA ENTERPRISE PROMOTION EQUIPMENT EXCHANGE RATE EXTERNAL DEBT EXTERNAL FINANCING EXTERNAL SHOCKS FARMERS FINANCE COMPANIES FINANCES FINANCIAL COSTS FINANCIAL HEALTH FINANCIAL INFORMATION FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS FINANCIAL MARKET FINANCIAL MARKETS FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE FINANCIAL RESOURCES FINANCIAL SECTOR ASSESSMENT FINANCIAL SECTOR DEVELOPMENTS FINANCIAL SECTOR REFORM FINANCIAL SERVICE FINANCIAL SERVICES FINANCIAL SERVICES PROVIDERS FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FINANCIAL STRUCTURE FINANCIAL SUPPORT FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY FINANCIAL SYSTEM FINANCIAL SYSTEMS FINANCIAL TOOL FINANCIAL TOOLS FINANCIAL TRAINING FINANCIAL VIABILITY FINANCING FACILITIES FOREIGN EXCHANGE FORMAL FINANCIAL SECTOR GUARANTEE FUND GUARANTEE FUNDS HUMAN RESOURCES ILLITERACY INCOME TAX INFLATION INFLATION RATE INFORMATION SHARING INFORMATION SYSTEM INFORMATION SYSTEMS INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENTS INSURANCE INSURANCE COMPANIES INTEREST INCOME INTEREST RATE INTEREST RATE POLICY INTEREST RATES INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT INTERNATIONAL INVESTORS INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS INVENTORY INVESTMENT RISK JOINT STOCK COMPANIES LACK OF INFORMATION LACK OF KNOWLEDGE LAND RECORDS LEGAL FRAMEWORK LEGAL SYSTEM LINES OF CREDIT LOAN LOAN COOPERATIVES LOAN CUSTOMERS LOAN DEFAULTS LOAN PORTFOLIO LOAN PORTFOLIOS LOAN REPAYMENT LOAN VOLUME LOCAL BANKS LOCAL CURRENCY LOCAL FINANCIAL MARKETS LONG-TERM INVESTMENTS LONG-TERM LOANS MACROECONOMIC STABILITY MACROECONOMIC STABILIZATION MARKET DISTORTIONS MARKET ECONOMY MERCHANT MERCHANTS MFI MFIS MICROCREDIT MICROFINANCE MICROFINANCE INSTITUTIONS MICROFINANCE SECTOR MONETARY FUND MONEYLENDERS MORTGAGES NATIONAL BANK NATIONAL BANKS OPERATING COSTS OUTREACH OUTSTANDING CREDIT OUTSTANDING LOANS PAYMENT HISTORY PENETRATION RATE POOR CLIENTS PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT PORTFOLIO QUALITY POST OFFICES POSTAL SAVINGS POTENTIAL INVESTORS PRIVATE CAPITAL PRIVATE INVESTORS PROFITABILITY PROVISIONING RULES REGISTRATION FEES REGULATORY FRAMEWORK REPAYMENTS RESERVES RETURN RETURN ON ASSETS RETURNS RISK MANAGEMENT RISK OF DEFAULT RURAL CREDIT RURAL FINANCE SAVINGS SAVINGS ACCOUNTS SAVINGS BANK SAVINGS BANKS SCHOLARSHIPS SHAREHOLDER SHAREHOLDERS SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT SUBSIDIZATION SUPERVISORY AUTHORITY SUPPLY OF CREDIT TAX EXEMPTIONS TAX PROVISIONS TAX SYSTEM TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE TECHNICAL SUPPORT TELECOMMUNICATIONS TERM CREDIT TRAINING CENTER TRANSACTION TRANSACTION COSTS TRANSPARENCY TREASURY TREASURY BILL TREASURY BILL RATE TREASURY BILLS TURNOVER UNFAIR COMPETITION UNION UNIONS VILLAGE Moyart, Manuel Duflos, Eric Latortue, Alexia Lecuyer, Francois Isern, Jennifer Rauch, Hubert Country-Level Effectiveness and Accountability Review : Madagascar |
| geographic_facet |
Africa Madagascar |
| description |
This Country-Level Effectiveness and
Accountability Review (CLEAR) examines the efficacy of
microfinance aid in Madagascar, based on an objective
analysis of donor assistance for the sustainable development
of financial systems targeting the poor. The three levels of
the financial system are the micro level (e.g., retail
institutions), the meso level (e.g., apex, technical service
providers), and the macro level (e.g., regulations and
policies). At the micro level, there is a large number of
stakeholders, and an increasing interest of banks and
private investors, including a predominant stake by the
Decentralized Financial Systems (DFS), as well as major
roles by the local Savings Institution and the Post Office.
At the meso level, there is a supply of services such as
auditing. Finally, at the macro level, coordination and
supervision exist, and a specific legal framework on
microfinance is in place. Notwithstanding, microfinance in
Madagascar remains weak, and, concerns suggest DFSs carry
structural weaknesses at various levels. Additionally, it is
specified services in support of microfinance are still
rare, and its quality it debatable. Professional
organizations need to be strengthened, particularly as lack
of reliable information on financial results is concerned.
At the macro level, supervisory and coordinating agencies
rely on limited means, whereas the legal framework is not
fully supportive. Risks suggest potential market disruptions
resulting from subsidies and interest rate hikes, an
implication by which the Ministry of Agriculture not always
agrees with the Microfinance National Strategy. Finally, the
judicial system does not rely enough in favor of the
development of the financial sector. |
| format |
Publications & Research :: Working Paper |
| author |
Moyart, Manuel Duflos, Eric Latortue, Alexia Lecuyer, Francois Isern, Jennifer Rauch, Hubert |
| author_facet |
Moyart, Manuel Duflos, Eric Latortue, Alexia Lecuyer, Francois Isern, Jennifer Rauch, Hubert |
| author_sort |
Moyart, Manuel |
| title |
Country-Level Effectiveness and Accountability Review : Madagascar |
| title_short |
Country-Level Effectiveness and Accountability Review : Madagascar |
| title_full |
Country-Level Effectiveness and Accountability Review : Madagascar |
| title_fullStr |
Country-Level Effectiveness and Accountability Review : Madagascar |
| title_full_unstemmed |
Country-Level Effectiveness and Accountability Review : Madagascar |
| title_sort |
country-level effectiveness and accountability review : madagascar |
| publisher |
CGAP and the World Bank, Washington, DC |
| publishDate |
2014 |
| url |
http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2005/10/18626355/country-level-effectiveness-accountability-review-clear-madagascar http://hdl.handle.net/10986/16961 |
| _version_ |
1764435356317384704 |
| spelling |
okr-10986-169612021-04-23T14:03:34Z Country-Level Effectiveness and Accountability Review : Madagascar Moyart, Manuel Duflos, Eric Latortue, Alexia Lecuyer, Francois Isern, Jennifer Rauch, Hubert ACCESS TO FINANCIAL SERVICES ACCESS TO TRAINING ACCOUNTING ADVOCACY ACTIVITIES AGRICULTURAL BANK AGRICULTURAL FINANCE AGRICULTURAL PRODUCT AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTS AID EFFECTIVENESS APEX INSTITUTIONS ARREARS AUCTION BALANCE SHEETS BANK BRANCHES BANK RATES BANKING LAW BANKING NETWORK BANKING REGULATIONS BANKING SECTOR BANKING SECTORS BANKING SUPERVISION BANKING SYSTEM BORROWING BUSINESS PLAN BUSINESS PLANS CAPACITY BUILDING CAPITAL MARKET CASH FLOWS CENTRAL BANK CHECKING ACCOUNTS COLLATERAL COLLECTIVE ACTION COMMERCIAL BANK COMMERCIAL BANKS COMPETITIVE BIDDING COOPERATIVE BANKS COOPERATIVES CORRUPTION COST OF CREDIT CREDIT AGENCY CREDIT ASSOCIATION CREDIT BANKS CREDIT BUREAUS CREDIT INFORMATION CREDIT INFORMATION BUREAU CREDIT SUPPORT CUSTOMER BASE DEBT DEEDS DEMAND FOR CREDIT DEPOSITS DEVALUATION DEVELOPING COUNTRIES DEVELOPMENT BANK DISCLOSURE GUIDELINES DIVERSIFICATION DONOR FUNDING DONOR FUNDS DONOR SUBSIDIES DONOR SUPPORT ECONOMIC COOPERATION ECONOMIC CRISES ECONOMIC CRISIS ECONOMIC GROWTH EDUCATION SYSTEM ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA ENTERPRISE PROMOTION EQUIPMENT EXCHANGE RATE EXTERNAL DEBT EXTERNAL FINANCING EXTERNAL SHOCKS FARMERS FINANCE COMPANIES FINANCES FINANCIAL COSTS FINANCIAL HEALTH FINANCIAL INFORMATION FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS FINANCIAL MARKET FINANCIAL MARKETS FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE FINANCIAL RESOURCES FINANCIAL SECTOR ASSESSMENT FINANCIAL SECTOR DEVELOPMENTS FINANCIAL SECTOR REFORM FINANCIAL SERVICE FINANCIAL SERVICES FINANCIAL SERVICES PROVIDERS FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FINANCIAL STRUCTURE FINANCIAL SUPPORT FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY FINANCIAL SYSTEM FINANCIAL SYSTEMS FINANCIAL TOOL FINANCIAL TOOLS FINANCIAL TRAINING FINANCIAL VIABILITY FINANCING FACILITIES FOREIGN EXCHANGE FORMAL FINANCIAL SECTOR GUARANTEE FUND GUARANTEE FUNDS HUMAN RESOURCES ILLITERACY INCOME TAX INFLATION INFLATION RATE INFORMATION SHARING INFORMATION SYSTEM INFORMATION SYSTEMS INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENTS INSURANCE INSURANCE COMPANIES INTEREST INCOME INTEREST RATE INTEREST RATE POLICY INTEREST RATES INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT INTERNATIONAL INVESTORS INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS INVENTORY INVESTMENT RISK JOINT STOCK COMPANIES LACK OF INFORMATION LACK OF KNOWLEDGE LAND RECORDS LEGAL FRAMEWORK LEGAL SYSTEM LINES OF CREDIT LOAN LOAN COOPERATIVES LOAN CUSTOMERS LOAN DEFAULTS LOAN PORTFOLIO LOAN PORTFOLIOS LOAN REPAYMENT LOAN VOLUME LOCAL BANKS LOCAL CURRENCY LOCAL FINANCIAL MARKETS LONG-TERM INVESTMENTS LONG-TERM LOANS MACROECONOMIC STABILITY MACROECONOMIC STABILIZATION MARKET DISTORTIONS MARKET ECONOMY MERCHANT MERCHANTS MFI MFIS MICROCREDIT MICROFINANCE MICROFINANCE INSTITUTIONS MICROFINANCE SECTOR MONETARY FUND MONEYLENDERS MORTGAGES NATIONAL BANK NATIONAL BANKS OPERATING COSTS OUTREACH OUTSTANDING CREDIT OUTSTANDING LOANS PAYMENT HISTORY PENETRATION RATE POOR CLIENTS PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT PORTFOLIO QUALITY POST OFFICES POSTAL SAVINGS POTENTIAL INVESTORS PRIVATE CAPITAL PRIVATE INVESTORS PROFITABILITY PROVISIONING RULES REGISTRATION FEES REGULATORY FRAMEWORK REPAYMENTS RESERVES RETURN RETURN ON ASSETS RETURNS RISK MANAGEMENT RISK OF DEFAULT RURAL CREDIT RURAL FINANCE SAVINGS SAVINGS ACCOUNTS SAVINGS BANK SAVINGS BANKS SCHOLARSHIPS SHAREHOLDER SHAREHOLDERS SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT SUBSIDIZATION SUPERVISORY AUTHORITY SUPPLY OF CREDIT TAX EXEMPTIONS TAX PROVISIONS TAX SYSTEM TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE TECHNICAL SUPPORT TELECOMMUNICATIONS TERM CREDIT TRAINING CENTER TRANSACTION TRANSACTION COSTS TRANSPARENCY TREASURY TREASURY BILL TREASURY BILL RATE TREASURY BILLS TURNOVER UNFAIR COMPETITION UNION UNIONS VILLAGE This Country-Level Effectiveness and Accountability Review (CLEAR) examines the efficacy of microfinance aid in Madagascar, based on an objective analysis of donor assistance for the sustainable development of financial systems targeting the poor. The three levels of the financial system are the micro level (e.g., retail institutions), the meso level (e.g., apex, technical service providers), and the macro level (e.g., regulations and policies). At the micro level, there is a large number of stakeholders, and an increasing interest of banks and private investors, including a predominant stake by the Decentralized Financial Systems (DFS), as well as major roles by the local Savings Institution and the Post Office. At the meso level, there is a supply of services such as auditing. Finally, at the macro level, coordination and supervision exist, and a specific legal framework on microfinance is in place. Notwithstanding, microfinance in Madagascar remains weak, and, concerns suggest DFSs carry structural weaknesses at various levels. Additionally, it is specified services in support of microfinance are still rare, and its quality it debatable. Professional organizations need to be strengthened, particularly as lack of reliable information on financial results is concerned. At the macro level, supervisory and coordinating agencies rely on limited means, whereas the legal framework is not fully supportive. Risks suggest potential market disruptions resulting from subsidies and interest rate hikes, an implication by which the Ministry of Agriculture not always agrees with the Microfinance National Strategy. Finally, the judicial system does not rely enough in favor of the development of the financial sector. 2014-02-10T19:14:28Z 2014-02-10T19:14:28Z 2005-10 http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2005/10/18626355/country-level-effectiveness-accountability-review-clear-madagascar http://hdl.handle.net/10986/16961 English en_US CC BY 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/ CGAP and the World Bank, Washington, DC Publications & Research :: Working Paper Publications & Research Africa Madagascar |