Carbon Price Efficiency : Lock-in and Path Dependence in Urban Forms and Transport Infrastructure
This paper investigates the effect of carbon or gasoline taxes on commuting-related CO2 emissions in an urban context. To assess the impact of public transport on the efficiency of the tax, the paper investigates two exogenous scenarios using a dyn...
| Main Authors: | , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Policy Research Working Paper |
| Language: | English en_US |
| Published: |
World Bank, Washington, DC
2014
|
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2014/06/19705748/carbon-price-efficiency-lock-in-path-dependence-urban-forms-transport-infrastructure http://hdl.handle.net/10986/18829 |
| id |
okr-10986-18829 |
|---|---|
| recordtype |
oai_dc |
| repository_type |
Digital Repository |
| institution_category |
Foreign Institution |
| institution |
Digital Repositories |
| building |
World Bank Open Knowledge Repository |
| collection |
World Bank |
| language |
English en_US |
| topic |
ABSOLUTE LEVEL OF EMISSIONS ACCESSIBILITY ACCIDENTS AIR AIR TRAVEL ALTERNATIVE FORMS OF TRANSPORT AUTOMOBILE AUTOMOBILE INDUSTRY AUTOMOBILES BUS BUSES CAR CAR COST CAR INDUSTRY CAR TECHNOLOGIES CAR TRANSPORT CAR TRAVEL CAR TRAVEL DEMAND CARBON CARBON BUDGET CARBON DIOXIDE CARBON DIOXIDE EMISSIONS CARBON EMISSION CARBON EMISSIONS CARBON PRICE CARBON TAX CARBON TAXES CARRIERS CARS CLIMATE CLIMATE CHANGE CO2 COMBUSTION COMMUTER MODE CHOICE COMMUTERS CONVERGENCE COST OF TRANSPORT COSTS OF TRANSPORT CROSS ELASTICITY CROSS-ELASTICITIES DECREASE IN EMISSIONS DEMAND ELASTICITIES DEMAND ELASTICITY DEMAND FOR AUTOMOBILE FUEL DEMAND FOR ROAD TRANSPORT DEMAND FOR TRANSPORT DEMAND FOR TRANSPORTATION DEMAND FOR TRANSPORTATION FUELS DRIVERS DRIVING ELASTICITIES ELASTICITIES OF ROAD TRAFFIC ELASTICITIES OF TRAVEL DEMAND ELASTICITY OF FUEL CONSUMPTION ELASTICITY VALUES ELECTRIC VEHICLES ELECTRICITY EMISSION EMISSION LEVEL EMISSION LEVELS EMISSION REDUCTION EMISSION REDUCTION TARGET EMISSION REDUCTIONS EMISSION-REDUCTION EMISSIONS EMISSIONS FROM TRANSPORT EMISSIONS REDUCTION ENERGY CONSUMPTION ENERGY POLICY ENVIRONMENTAL TAXES EXTERNALITIES FINANCE INFRASTRUCTURE FINANCIAL BURDEN FOSSIL FUEL FOSSIL FUELS FUEL FUEL CONSUMPTION FUEL ECONOMY FUEL EFFICIENCY FUEL EFFICIENT VEHICLES FUEL PRICE FUEL PRICE ELASTICITIES FUEL PRICE ELASTICITY FUEL PRICE INCREASE FUEL PRICE INCREASES FUEL PRICES FUEL TAXATION FUEL TAXES FUEL-EFFICIENT VEHICLES GASOLINE GASOLINE CONSUMPTION GASOLINE PRICE GASOLINE PRICES GASOLINE TAX GASOLINE TAXES GHG GLOBAL WARMING GREENHOUSE GREENHOUSE GAS GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS HYBRID CARS IMPACT OF ROAD PRICING INCOME INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENT INFRASTRUCTURE POLICIES INFRASTRUCTURES INTERNAL COMBUSTION ENGINES JOURNEY LAND USE LOCAL AIR POLLUTION LONG RUN ELASTICITIES LONG-TERM ELASTICITIES LONG-TERM ELASTICITY LOW-CARBON MARGINAL ABATEMENT MARGINAL ABATEMENT COST MEANS OF TRANSPORT MOBILITY MODAL CHOICE MODAL SHARE MODAL SHIFT MODAL SPLIT MODE OF TRANSPORT NEGATIVE IMPACT NEIGHBORHOODS NOISE NUCLEAR ENERGY PASSENGERS POPULATION DENSITIES POPULATION DENSITY POPULATION GROWTH PRICE CHANGES PRICE ELASTICITIES PRICE ELASTICITY PRICE ELASTICITY OF DEMAND PRICE ELASTICITY OF GASOLINE PRICE INCENTIVES PRICE OF FUEL PRICE OF GASOLINE PRIVATE MOTOR VEHICLE PRIVATE VEHICLES PUBLIC TRANSIT PUBLIC TRANSIT NETWORK PUBLIC TRANSPORT PUBLIC TRANSPORT ALTERNATIVES PUBLIC TRANSPORT INFRASTRUCTURE PUBLIC TRANSPORT INVESTMENTS PUBLIC TRANSPORT MODES PUBLIC TRANSPORT NETWORK PUBLIC TRANSPORT NETWORKS PUBLIC TRANSPORT PROVISION PUBLIC TRANSPORT SERVICE PUBLIC TRANSPORT SYSTEM PUBLIC TRANSPORT SYSTEMS PUBLIC TRANSPORT USAGE PUBLIC TRANSPORT USE PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION RAIL RAIL TRANSPORT REBATES RISK MANAGEMENT ROAD ROAD CONGESTION ROAD TRAFFIC ROAD TRANSPORT ROADS ROUTE SCENARIOS SOCIAL COST OF CARBON SPRAWL TAX TAX REVENUE TRAFFIC DEMAND TRAFFIC ELASTICITIES TRAFFIC PSYCHOLOGY TRANSIT INFRASTRUCTURE TRANSIT SYSTEM TRANSIT USAGE TRANSIT USE TRANSPORT TRANSPORT CHOICES TRANSPORT COSTS TRANSPORT DEMAND TRANSPORT ECONOMICS TRANSPORT ELASTICITIES TRANSPORT EMISSIONS TRANSPORT IMPACTS TRANSPORT INFRASTRUCTURE TRANSPORT MODE TRANSPORT POLICIES TRANSPORT POLICY TRANSPORT PRICE TRANSPORT SECTOR TRANSPORT SUBSIDIES TRANSPORTATION COSTS TRANSPORTATION ECONOMICS TRANSPORTATION EMISSIONS TRANSPORTATION NETWORKS TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM TRANSPORTS TRAVEL BEHAVIOR TRAVEL DISTANCES TRAVEL MODE TRAVEL OPTIONS TRIP TRIPS URBAN SPRAWL URBAN SYSTEMS URBAN TRANSPORTATION VEHICLE VEHICLE FLEET VEHICLES WALKING |
| spellingShingle |
ABSOLUTE LEVEL OF EMISSIONS ACCESSIBILITY ACCIDENTS AIR AIR TRAVEL ALTERNATIVE FORMS OF TRANSPORT AUTOMOBILE AUTOMOBILE INDUSTRY AUTOMOBILES BUS BUSES CAR CAR COST CAR INDUSTRY CAR TECHNOLOGIES CAR TRANSPORT CAR TRAVEL CAR TRAVEL DEMAND CARBON CARBON BUDGET CARBON DIOXIDE CARBON DIOXIDE EMISSIONS CARBON EMISSION CARBON EMISSIONS CARBON PRICE CARBON TAX CARBON TAXES CARRIERS CARS CLIMATE CLIMATE CHANGE CO2 COMBUSTION COMMUTER MODE CHOICE COMMUTERS CONVERGENCE COST OF TRANSPORT COSTS OF TRANSPORT CROSS ELASTICITY CROSS-ELASTICITIES DECREASE IN EMISSIONS DEMAND ELASTICITIES DEMAND ELASTICITY DEMAND FOR AUTOMOBILE FUEL DEMAND FOR ROAD TRANSPORT DEMAND FOR TRANSPORT DEMAND FOR TRANSPORTATION DEMAND FOR TRANSPORTATION FUELS DRIVERS DRIVING ELASTICITIES ELASTICITIES OF ROAD TRAFFIC ELASTICITIES OF TRAVEL DEMAND ELASTICITY OF FUEL CONSUMPTION ELASTICITY VALUES ELECTRIC VEHICLES ELECTRICITY EMISSION EMISSION LEVEL EMISSION LEVELS EMISSION REDUCTION EMISSION REDUCTION TARGET EMISSION REDUCTIONS EMISSION-REDUCTION EMISSIONS EMISSIONS FROM TRANSPORT EMISSIONS REDUCTION ENERGY CONSUMPTION ENERGY POLICY ENVIRONMENTAL TAXES EXTERNALITIES FINANCE INFRASTRUCTURE FINANCIAL BURDEN FOSSIL FUEL FOSSIL FUELS FUEL FUEL CONSUMPTION FUEL ECONOMY FUEL EFFICIENCY FUEL EFFICIENT VEHICLES FUEL PRICE FUEL PRICE ELASTICITIES FUEL PRICE ELASTICITY FUEL PRICE INCREASE FUEL PRICE INCREASES FUEL PRICES FUEL TAXATION FUEL TAXES FUEL-EFFICIENT VEHICLES GASOLINE GASOLINE CONSUMPTION GASOLINE PRICE GASOLINE PRICES GASOLINE TAX GASOLINE TAXES GHG GLOBAL WARMING GREENHOUSE GREENHOUSE GAS GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS HYBRID CARS IMPACT OF ROAD PRICING INCOME INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENT INFRASTRUCTURE POLICIES INFRASTRUCTURES INTERNAL COMBUSTION ENGINES JOURNEY LAND USE LOCAL AIR POLLUTION LONG RUN ELASTICITIES LONG-TERM ELASTICITIES LONG-TERM ELASTICITY LOW-CARBON MARGINAL ABATEMENT MARGINAL ABATEMENT COST MEANS OF TRANSPORT MOBILITY MODAL CHOICE MODAL SHARE MODAL SHIFT MODAL SPLIT MODE OF TRANSPORT NEGATIVE IMPACT NEIGHBORHOODS NOISE NUCLEAR ENERGY PASSENGERS POPULATION DENSITIES POPULATION DENSITY POPULATION GROWTH PRICE CHANGES PRICE ELASTICITIES PRICE ELASTICITY PRICE ELASTICITY OF DEMAND PRICE ELASTICITY OF GASOLINE PRICE INCENTIVES PRICE OF FUEL PRICE OF GASOLINE PRIVATE MOTOR VEHICLE PRIVATE VEHICLES PUBLIC TRANSIT PUBLIC TRANSIT NETWORK PUBLIC TRANSPORT PUBLIC TRANSPORT ALTERNATIVES PUBLIC TRANSPORT INFRASTRUCTURE PUBLIC TRANSPORT INVESTMENTS PUBLIC TRANSPORT MODES PUBLIC TRANSPORT NETWORK PUBLIC TRANSPORT NETWORKS PUBLIC TRANSPORT PROVISION PUBLIC TRANSPORT SERVICE PUBLIC TRANSPORT SYSTEM PUBLIC TRANSPORT SYSTEMS PUBLIC TRANSPORT USAGE PUBLIC TRANSPORT USE PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION RAIL RAIL TRANSPORT REBATES RISK MANAGEMENT ROAD ROAD CONGESTION ROAD TRAFFIC ROAD TRANSPORT ROADS ROUTE SCENARIOS SOCIAL COST OF CARBON SPRAWL TAX TAX REVENUE TRAFFIC DEMAND TRAFFIC ELASTICITIES TRAFFIC PSYCHOLOGY TRANSIT INFRASTRUCTURE TRANSIT SYSTEM TRANSIT USAGE TRANSIT USE TRANSPORT TRANSPORT CHOICES TRANSPORT COSTS TRANSPORT DEMAND TRANSPORT ECONOMICS TRANSPORT ELASTICITIES TRANSPORT EMISSIONS TRANSPORT IMPACTS TRANSPORT INFRASTRUCTURE TRANSPORT MODE TRANSPORT POLICIES TRANSPORT POLICY TRANSPORT PRICE TRANSPORT SECTOR TRANSPORT SUBSIDIES TRANSPORTATION COSTS TRANSPORTATION ECONOMICS TRANSPORTATION EMISSIONS TRANSPORTATION NETWORKS TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM TRANSPORTS TRAVEL BEHAVIOR TRAVEL DISTANCES TRAVEL MODE TRAVEL OPTIONS TRIP TRIPS URBAN SPRAWL URBAN SYSTEMS URBAN TRANSPORTATION VEHICLE VEHICLE FLEET VEHICLES WALKING Avner, Paolo Rentschler, Jun Hallegatte, Stéphane Carbon Price Efficiency : Lock-in and Path Dependence in Urban Forms and Transport Infrastructure |
| relation |
Policy Research Working Paper;No. 6941 |
| description |
This paper investigates the effect of
carbon or gasoline taxes on commuting-related CO2 emissions
in an urban context. To assess the impact of public
transport on the efficiency of the tax, the paper
investigates two exogenous scenarios using a dynamic urban
model (NEDUM-2D) calibrated for the urban area of Paris: (i)
a scenario with the current dense public transport
infrastructure, and (ii) a scenario without. It is shown
that the price elasticity of CO2 emissions is twice as high
in the short run if public transport options exist. Reducing
commuting-related emissions thus requires lower (and more
acceptable) tax levels in the presence of dense public
transportation. If the goal of a carbon or gasoline tax is
to change behaviors and reduce energy consumption and CO2
emissions (not to raise revenues), then there is an
incentive to increase the price elasticity through
complementary policies such as public transport development.
The emission elasticity also depends on the baseline
scenario and is larger when population growth and income
growth are high. In the longer run, elasticities are higher
and similar in the scenarios with and without public
transport, because of larger urban reconfiguration in the
latter scenario. These results are policy relevant,
especially for fast-growing cities in developing countries.
Even for cities where emission reductions are not a priority
today, there is an option value attached to a dense public
transport network, since it makes it possible to reduce
emissions at a lower cost in the future. |
| format |
Publications & Research :: Policy Research Working Paper |
| author |
Avner, Paolo Rentschler, Jun Hallegatte, Stéphane |
| author_facet |
Avner, Paolo Rentschler, Jun Hallegatte, Stéphane |
| author_sort |
Avner, Paolo |
| title |
Carbon Price Efficiency : Lock-in and Path Dependence in Urban Forms and Transport Infrastructure |
| title_short |
Carbon Price Efficiency : Lock-in and Path Dependence in Urban Forms and Transport Infrastructure |
| title_full |
Carbon Price Efficiency : Lock-in and Path Dependence in Urban Forms and Transport Infrastructure |
| title_fullStr |
Carbon Price Efficiency : Lock-in and Path Dependence in Urban Forms and Transport Infrastructure |
| title_full_unstemmed |
Carbon Price Efficiency : Lock-in and Path Dependence in Urban Forms and Transport Infrastructure |
| title_sort |
carbon price efficiency : lock-in and path dependence in urban forms and transport infrastructure |
| publisher |
World Bank, Washington, DC |
| publishDate |
2014 |
| url |
http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2014/06/19705748/carbon-price-efficiency-lock-in-path-dependence-urban-forms-transport-infrastructure http://hdl.handle.net/10986/18829 |
| _version_ |
1764442839423385600 |
| spelling |
okr-10986-188292021-04-23T14:03:49Z Carbon Price Efficiency : Lock-in and Path Dependence in Urban Forms and Transport Infrastructure Avner, Paolo Rentschler, Jun Hallegatte, Stéphane ABSOLUTE LEVEL OF EMISSIONS ACCESSIBILITY ACCIDENTS AIR AIR TRAVEL ALTERNATIVE FORMS OF TRANSPORT AUTOMOBILE AUTOMOBILE INDUSTRY AUTOMOBILES BUS BUSES CAR CAR COST CAR INDUSTRY CAR TECHNOLOGIES CAR TRANSPORT CAR TRAVEL CAR TRAVEL DEMAND CARBON CARBON BUDGET CARBON DIOXIDE CARBON DIOXIDE EMISSIONS CARBON EMISSION CARBON EMISSIONS CARBON PRICE CARBON TAX CARBON TAXES CARRIERS CARS CLIMATE CLIMATE CHANGE CO2 COMBUSTION COMMUTER MODE CHOICE COMMUTERS CONVERGENCE COST OF TRANSPORT COSTS OF TRANSPORT CROSS ELASTICITY CROSS-ELASTICITIES DECREASE IN EMISSIONS DEMAND ELASTICITIES DEMAND ELASTICITY DEMAND FOR AUTOMOBILE FUEL DEMAND FOR ROAD TRANSPORT DEMAND FOR TRANSPORT DEMAND FOR TRANSPORTATION DEMAND FOR TRANSPORTATION FUELS DRIVERS DRIVING ELASTICITIES ELASTICITIES OF ROAD TRAFFIC ELASTICITIES OF TRAVEL DEMAND ELASTICITY OF FUEL CONSUMPTION ELASTICITY VALUES ELECTRIC VEHICLES ELECTRICITY EMISSION EMISSION LEVEL EMISSION LEVELS EMISSION REDUCTION EMISSION REDUCTION TARGET EMISSION REDUCTIONS EMISSION-REDUCTION EMISSIONS EMISSIONS FROM TRANSPORT EMISSIONS REDUCTION ENERGY CONSUMPTION ENERGY POLICY ENVIRONMENTAL TAXES EXTERNALITIES FINANCE INFRASTRUCTURE FINANCIAL BURDEN FOSSIL FUEL FOSSIL FUELS FUEL FUEL CONSUMPTION FUEL ECONOMY FUEL EFFICIENCY FUEL EFFICIENT VEHICLES FUEL PRICE FUEL PRICE ELASTICITIES FUEL PRICE ELASTICITY FUEL PRICE INCREASE FUEL PRICE INCREASES FUEL PRICES FUEL TAXATION FUEL TAXES FUEL-EFFICIENT VEHICLES GASOLINE GASOLINE CONSUMPTION GASOLINE PRICE GASOLINE PRICES GASOLINE TAX GASOLINE TAXES GHG GLOBAL WARMING GREENHOUSE GREENHOUSE GAS GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS HYBRID CARS IMPACT OF ROAD PRICING INCOME INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENT INFRASTRUCTURE POLICIES INFRASTRUCTURES INTERNAL COMBUSTION ENGINES JOURNEY LAND USE LOCAL AIR POLLUTION LONG RUN ELASTICITIES LONG-TERM ELASTICITIES LONG-TERM ELASTICITY LOW-CARBON MARGINAL ABATEMENT MARGINAL ABATEMENT COST MEANS OF TRANSPORT MOBILITY MODAL CHOICE MODAL SHARE MODAL SHIFT MODAL SPLIT MODE OF TRANSPORT NEGATIVE IMPACT NEIGHBORHOODS NOISE NUCLEAR ENERGY PASSENGERS POPULATION DENSITIES POPULATION DENSITY POPULATION GROWTH PRICE CHANGES PRICE ELASTICITIES PRICE ELASTICITY PRICE ELASTICITY OF DEMAND PRICE ELASTICITY OF GASOLINE PRICE INCENTIVES PRICE OF FUEL PRICE OF GASOLINE PRIVATE MOTOR VEHICLE PRIVATE VEHICLES PUBLIC TRANSIT PUBLIC TRANSIT NETWORK PUBLIC TRANSPORT PUBLIC TRANSPORT ALTERNATIVES PUBLIC TRANSPORT INFRASTRUCTURE PUBLIC TRANSPORT INVESTMENTS PUBLIC TRANSPORT MODES PUBLIC TRANSPORT NETWORK PUBLIC TRANSPORT NETWORKS PUBLIC TRANSPORT PROVISION PUBLIC TRANSPORT SERVICE PUBLIC TRANSPORT SYSTEM PUBLIC TRANSPORT SYSTEMS PUBLIC TRANSPORT USAGE PUBLIC TRANSPORT USE PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION RAIL RAIL TRANSPORT REBATES RISK MANAGEMENT ROAD ROAD CONGESTION ROAD TRAFFIC ROAD TRANSPORT ROADS ROUTE SCENARIOS SOCIAL COST OF CARBON SPRAWL TAX TAX REVENUE TRAFFIC DEMAND TRAFFIC ELASTICITIES TRAFFIC PSYCHOLOGY TRANSIT INFRASTRUCTURE TRANSIT SYSTEM TRANSIT USAGE TRANSIT USE TRANSPORT TRANSPORT CHOICES TRANSPORT COSTS TRANSPORT DEMAND TRANSPORT ECONOMICS TRANSPORT ELASTICITIES TRANSPORT EMISSIONS TRANSPORT IMPACTS TRANSPORT INFRASTRUCTURE TRANSPORT MODE TRANSPORT POLICIES TRANSPORT POLICY TRANSPORT PRICE TRANSPORT SECTOR TRANSPORT SUBSIDIES TRANSPORTATION COSTS TRANSPORTATION ECONOMICS TRANSPORTATION EMISSIONS TRANSPORTATION NETWORKS TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM TRANSPORTS TRAVEL BEHAVIOR TRAVEL DISTANCES TRAVEL MODE TRAVEL OPTIONS TRIP TRIPS URBAN SPRAWL URBAN SYSTEMS URBAN TRANSPORTATION VEHICLE VEHICLE FLEET VEHICLES WALKING This paper investigates the effect of carbon or gasoline taxes on commuting-related CO2 emissions in an urban context. To assess the impact of public transport on the efficiency of the tax, the paper investigates two exogenous scenarios using a dynamic urban model (NEDUM-2D) calibrated for the urban area of Paris: (i) a scenario with the current dense public transport infrastructure, and (ii) a scenario without. It is shown that the price elasticity of CO2 emissions is twice as high in the short run if public transport options exist. Reducing commuting-related emissions thus requires lower (and more acceptable) tax levels in the presence of dense public transportation. If the goal of a carbon or gasoline tax is to change behaviors and reduce energy consumption and CO2 emissions (not to raise revenues), then there is an incentive to increase the price elasticity through complementary policies such as public transport development. The emission elasticity also depends on the baseline scenario and is larger when population growth and income growth are high. In the longer run, elasticities are higher and similar in the scenarios with and without public transport, because of larger urban reconfiguration in the latter scenario. These results are policy relevant, especially for fast-growing cities in developing countries. Even for cities where emission reductions are not a priority today, there is an option value attached to a dense public transport network, since it makes it possible to reduce emissions at a lower cost in the future. 2014-06-30T16:57:25Z 2014-06-30T16:57:25Z 2014-06 http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2014/06/19705748/carbon-price-efficiency-lock-in-path-dependence-urban-forms-transport-infrastructure http://hdl.handle.net/10986/18829 English en_US Policy Research Working Paper;No. 6941 CC BY 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/ World Bank, Washington, DC Publications & Research :: Policy Research Working Paper Publications & Research |