Promotion with and without Learning : Effects on Student Enrollment and Dropout Behavior
Many educators and policymakers have argued for lenient grade promotion policy - even automatic promotion - in developing country settings where grade retention rates are high. The argument assumes that grade retention discourages persistence or co...
| Main Authors: | , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Policy Research Working Paper |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
World Bank, Washington, DC
2012
|
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2008/09/9881999/promotion-without-learning-effects-student-enrollment-dropout-behavior http://hdl.handle.net/10986/6974 |
| id |
okr-10986-6974 |
|---|---|
| recordtype |
oai_dc |
| repository_type |
Digital Repository |
| institution_category |
Foreign Institution |
| institution |
Digital Repositories |
| building |
World Bank Open Knowledge Repository |
| collection |
World Bank |
| language |
English |
| topic |
ABSENTEEISM RATES ACADEMIC ACCOMPLISHMENTS ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ACADEMIC PROGRESS ACADEMIC YEAR ACHIEVEMENT IN MATHEMATICS ACHIEVEMENT TESTS AGE-GRADE DISTORTION APTITUDE ASSESSMENT SYSTEM ATTENDANCE RATE AVERAGE SCORE AVERAGE TEST SCORES BASIC EDUCATION BASIC EDUCATION SYSTEM BASIC LITERACY BOOK DEVELOPMENT BOOK PROVISION CENTRAL AMERICAN CHILD EDUCATION CLASS SIZE CLASSROOM CLASSROOMS COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION COMPETENCIES COMPULSORY EDUCATION CURRICULUM DAY SCHOOL DECENTRALIZATION DECISION MAKING DEGREES DISTANCE TO SCHOOL DROPOUT RATES EARLY DROPOUT EARLY GRADES ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS OF EDUCATION EDUCATED PARENTS EDUCATION LAW EDUCATION MANAGEMENT EDUCATION POLICIES EDUCATION POLICY EDUCATIONAL ACHIEVEMENTS EDUCATIONAL DEVELOPMENT EDUCATIONAL EVALUATION EDUCATIONAL OUTCOMES EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH EDUCATORS EFFECTIVE SCHOOLS EIGHTH-GRADERS ELEMENTS ENTRANCE EXAMINATION EXAM EXAMS GENDER DIFFERENCES GIRLS GRADE REPETITION GRADE RETENTION HIGH SCHOOL HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS HIGHER GRADES HIGHER TEST SCORES HUMAN CAPITAL HUMAN CAPITAL EARNINGS HUMAN DEVELOPMENT HUMAN RESOURCES ILLITERATE PARENTS IMPROVING PRIMARY EDUCATION INSTRUCTION KINDERGARTEN LABOR FORCE LANGUAGE OF INSTRUCTION LEARNING LITERACY LITERATURE LOCAL SCHOOLS LOWER ACHIEVEMENT MALE STUDENT MATH ACHIEVEMENT NUMBER OF STUDENTS NUMERACY OFFICIAL CURRICULUM OLDER CHILDREN PAPERS PARENTAL INVOLVEMENT PEER GROUP POOR PEOPLE PRIMARY CYCLE PRIMARY EDUCATION PRIMARY LEVEL PRIMARY SCHOOL PRIMARY SCHOOL EFFECTIVENESS PRIMARY SCHOOLING PRIMARY SCHOOLS PRIVATE SCHOOL PRIVATE SCHOOLS PUBLIC SCHOOL QUALITY EDUCATION QUALITY SCHOOLS RATES OF RETURN REMEDIAL EDUCATION REPEATERS REPETITION RATE REPETITION RATES RESEARCHERS RETENTION RATE RETENTION RATES SCHOOL ADJUSTMENT SCHOOL ATTENDANCE SCHOOL AUTONOMY SCHOOL COST SCHOOL DAY SCHOOL DAYS SCHOOL ENROLLMENT SCHOOL FACILITIES SCHOOL LEVEL SCHOOL PERFORMANCE SCHOOL QUALITY SCHOOL RECORDS SCHOOL SUPPORT SCHOOL SYSTEM SCHOOL SYSTEMS SCHOOL YEAR SCHOOL YEARS SCHOOLING SCHOOLS SECONDARY SCHOOL SOUTH AMERICAN STANDARDIZED TESTS STUDENT ABSENTEEISM STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT STUDENT ASSESSMENT STUDENT ASSESSMENTS STUDENT ATTAINMENT STUDENT ATTENDANCE STUDENT DROPOUT STUDENT ENROLLMENT STUDENT LEARNING STUDENT OUTCOMES STUDENT PERFORMANCE STUDENT SKILLS TEACHER TEACHER ABSENTEEISM TEACHER ATTITUDES TEACHER INCENTIVES TEACHER PROMOTION TEACHERS TEST SCORES TESTS OF MATHEMATICS TEXTBOOK |
| spellingShingle |
ABSENTEEISM RATES ACADEMIC ACCOMPLISHMENTS ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ACADEMIC PROGRESS ACADEMIC YEAR ACHIEVEMENT IN MATHEMATICS ACHIEVEMENT TESTS AGE-GRADE DISTORTION APTITUDE ASSESSMENT SYSTEM ATTENDANCE RATE AVERAGE SCORE AVERAGE TEST SCORES BASIC EDUCATION BASIC EDUCATION SYSTEM BASIC LITERACY BOOK DEVELOPMENT BOOK PROVISION CENTRAL AMERICAN CHILD EDUCATION CLASS SIZE CLASSROOM CLASSROOMS COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION COMPETENCIES COMPULSORY EDUCATION CURRICULUM DAY SCHOOL DECENTRALIZATION DECISION MAKING DEGREES DISTANCE TO SCHOOL DROPOUT RATES EARLY DROPOUT EARLY GRADES ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS OF EDUCATION EDUCATED PARENTS EDUCATION LAW EDUCATION MANAGEMENT EDUCATION POLICIES EDUCATION POLICY EDUCATIONAL ACHIEVEMENTS EDUCATIONAL DEVELOPMENT EDUCATIONAL EVALUATION EDUCATIONAL OUTCOMES EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH EDUCATORS EFFECTIVE SCHOOLS EIGHTH-GRADERS ELEMENTS ENTRANCE EXAMINATION EXAM EXAMS GENDER DIFFERENCES GIRLS GRADE REPETITION GRADE RETENTION HIGH SCHOOL HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS HIGHER GRADES HIGHER TEST SCORES HUMAN CAPITAL HUMAN CAPITAL EARNINGS HUMAN DEVELOPMENT HUMAN RESOURCES ILLITERATE PARENTS IMPROVING PRIMARY EDUCATION INSTRUCTION KINDERGARTEN LABOR FORCE LANGUAGE OF INSTRUCTION LEARNING LITERACY LITERATURE LOCAL SCHOOLS LOWER ACHIEVEMENT MALE STUDENT MATH ACHIEVEMENT NUMBER OF STUDENTS NUMERACY OFFICIAL CURRICULUM OLDER CHILDREN PAPERS PARENTAL INVOLVEMENT PEER GROUP POOR PEOPLE PRIMARY CYCLE PRIMARY EDUCATION PRIMARY LEVEL PRIMARY SCHOOL PRIMARY SCHOOL EFFECTIVENESS PRIMARY SCHOOLING PRIMARY SCHOOLS PRIVATE SCHOOL PRIVATE SCHOOLS PUBLIC SCHOOL QUALITY EDUCATION QUALITY SCHOOLS RATES OF RETURN REMEDIAL EDUCATION REPEATERS REPETITION RATE REPETITION RATES RESEARCHERS RETENTION RATE RETENTION RATES SCHOOL ADJUSTMENT SCHOOL ATTENDANCE SCHOOL AUTONOMY SCHOOL COST SCHOOL DAY SCHOOL DAYS SCHOOL ENROLLMENT SCHOOL FACILITIES SCHOOL LEVEL SCHOOL PERFORMANCE SCHOOL QUALITY SCHOOL RECORDS SCHOOL SUPPORT SCHOOL SYSTEM SCHOOL SYSTEMS SCHOOL YEAR SCHOOL YEARS SCHOOLING SCHOOLS SECONDARY SCHOOL SOUTH AMERICAN STANDARDIZED TESTS STUDENT ABSENTEEISM STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT STUDENT ASSESSMENT STUDENT ASSESSMENTS STUDENT ATTAINMENT STUDENT ATTENDANCE STUDENT DROPOUT STUDENT ENROLLMENT STUDENT LEARNING STUDENT OUTCOMES STUDENT PERFORMANCE STUDENT SKILLS TEACHER TEACHER ABSENTEEISM TEACHER ATTITUDES TEACHER INCENTIVES TEACHER PROMOTION TEACHERS TEST SCORES TESTS OF MATHEMATICS TEXTBOOK King, Elizabeth M. Orazem, Peter F. Paterno, Elizabeth M. Promotion with and without Learning : Effects on Student Enrollment and Dropout Behavior |
| geographic_facet |
South Asia Pakistan |
| relation |
Policy Research Working Paper No. 4722 |
| description |
Many educators and policymakers have
argued for lenient grade promotion policy - even automatic
promotion - in developing country settings where grade
retention rates are high. The argument assumes that grade
retention discourages persistence or continuation in school
and that the promotion of children with lower achievement
does not hamper their ability or their peers' ability
to perform at the next level. Alternatively, promoting
students into grades for which they are not prepared may
lead to early dropout behavior. This study shows that in a
sample of schools from the Northwest Frontier Province of
Pakistan, students are promoted primarily on the basis of
merit. An econometric decomposition of promotion decisions
into a component that is based on merit indicators
(attendance and achievement in mathematics and language) and
another that is uncorrelated with those indicators allows a
test of whether parental decisions to keep their child in
school is influenced by merit-based or non-merit-based
promotions. Results suggest that the enrollment decision is
significantly influenced by whether learning has taken
place, and that grade promotion that is uncorrelated with
merit has a negligible impact on school continuation. |
| format |
Publications & Research :: Policy Research Working Paper |
| author |
King, Elizabeth M. Orazem, Peter F. Paterno, Elizabeth M. |
| author_facet |
King, Elizabeth M. Orazem, Peter F. Paterno, Elizabeth M. |
| author_sort |
King, Elizabeth M. |
| title |
Promotion with and without Learning : Effects on Student Enrollment and Dropout Behavior |
| title_short |
Promotion with and without Learning : Effects on Student Enrollment and Dropout Behavior |
| title_full |
Promotion with and without Learning : Effects on Student Enrollment and Dropout Behavior |
| title_fullStr |
Promotion with and without Learning : Effects on Student Enrollment and Dropout Behavior |
| title_full_unstemmed |
Promotion with and without Learning : Effects on Student Enrollment and Dropout Behavior |
| title_sort |
promotion with and without learning : effects on student enrollment and dropout behavior |
| publisher |
World Bank, Washington, DC |
| publishDate |
2012 |
| url |
http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2008/09/9881999/promotion-without-learning-effects-student-enrollment-dropout-behavior http://hdl.handle.net/10986/6974 |
| _version_ |
1764401181459742720 |
| spelling |
okr-10986-69742021-04-23T14:02:32Z Promotion with and without Learning : Effects on Student Enrollment and Dropout Behavior King, Elizabeth M. Orazem, Peter F. Paterno, Elizabeth M. ABSENTEEISM RATES ACADEMIC ACCOMPLISHMENTS ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ACADEMIC PROGRESS ACADEMIC YEAR ACHIEVEMENT IN MATHEMATICS ACHIEVEMENT TESTS AGE-GRADE DISTORTION APTITUDE ASSESSMENT SYSTEM ATTENDANCE RATE AVERAGE SCORE AVERAGE TEST SCORES BASIC EDUCATION BASIC EDUCATION SYSTEM BASIC LITERACY BOOK DEVELOPMENT BOOK PROVISION CENTRAL AMERICAN CHILD EDUCATION CLASS SIZE CLASSROOM CLASSROOMS COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION COMPETENCIES COMPULSORY EDUCATION CURRICULUM DAY SCHOOL DECENTRALIZATION DECISION MAKING DEGREES DISTANCE TO SCHOOL DROPOUT RATES EARLY DROPOUT EARLY GRADES ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS OF EDUCATION EDUCATED PARENTS EDUCATION LAW EDUCATION MANAGEMENT EDUCATION POLICIES EDUCATION POLICY EDUCATIONAL ACHIEVEMENTS EDUCATIONAL DEVELOPMENT EDUCATIONAL EVALUATION EDUCATIONAL OUTCOMES EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH EDUCATORS EFFECTIVE SCHOOLS EIGHTH-GRADERS ELEMENTS ENTRANCE EXAMINATION EXAM EXAMS GENDER DIFFERENCES GIRLS GRADE REPETITION GRADE RETENTION HIGH SCHOOL HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS HIGHER GRADES HIGHER TEST SCORES HUMAN CAPITAL HUMAN CAPITAL EARNINGS HUMAN DEVELOPMENT HUMAN RESOURCES ILLITERATE PARENTS IMPROVING PRIMARY EDUCATION INSTRUCTION KINDERGARTEN LABOR FORCE LANGUAGE OF INSTRUCTION LEARNING LITERACY LITERATURE LOCAL SCHOOLS LOWER ACHIEVEMENT MALE STUDENT MATH ACHIEVEMENT NUMBER OF STUDENTS NUMERACY OFFICIAL CURRICULUM OLDER CHILDREN PAPERS PARENTAL INVOLVEMENT PEER GROUP POOR PEOPLE PRIMARY CYCLE PRIMARY EDUCATION PRIMARY LEVEL PRIMARY SCHOOL PRIMARY SCHOOL EFFECTIVENESS PRIMARY SCHOOLING PRIMARY SCHOOLS PRIVATE SCHOOL PRIVATE SCHOOLS PUBLIC SCHOOL QUALITY EDUCATION QUALITY SCHOOLS RATES OF RETURN REMEDIAL EDUCATION REPEATERS REPETITION RATE REPETITION RATES RESEARCHERS RETENTION RATE RETENTION RATES SCHOOL ADJUSTMENT SCHOOL ATTENDANCE SCHOOL AUTONOMY SCHOOL COST SCHOOL DAY SCHOOL DAYS SCHOOL ENROLLMENT SCHOOL FACILITIES SCHOOL LEVEL SCHOOL PERFORMANCE SCHOOL QUALITY SCHOOL RECORDS SCHOOL SUPPORT SCHOOL SYSTEM SCHOOL SYSTEMS SCHOOL YEAR SCHOOL YEARS SCHOOLING SCHOOLS SECONDARY SCHOOL SOUTH AMERICAN STANDARDIZED TESTS STUDENT ABSENTEEISM STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT STUDENT ASSESSMENT STUDENT ASSESSMENTS STUDENT ATTAINMENT STUDENT ATTENDANCE STUDENT DROPOUT STUDENT ENROLLMENT STUDENT LEARNING STUDENT OUTCOMES STUDENT PERFORMANCE STUDENT SKILLS TEACHER TEACHER ABSENTEEISM TEACHER ATTITUDES TEACHER INCENTIVES TEACHER PROMOTION TEACHERS TEST SCORES TESTS OF MATHEMATICS TEXTBOOK Many educators and policymakers have argued for lenient grade promotion policy - even automatic promotion - in developing country settings where grade retention rates are high. The argument assumes that grade retention discourages persistence or continuation in school and that the promotion of children with lower achievement does not hamper their ability or their peers' ability to perform at the next level. Alternatively, promoting students into grades for which they are not prepared may lead to early dropout behavior. This study shows that in a sample of schools from the Northwest Frontier Province of Pakistan, students are promoted primarily on the basis of merit. An econometric decomposition of promotion decisions into a component that is based on merit indicators (attendance and achievement in mathematics and language) and another that is uncorrelated with those indicators allows a test of whether parental decisions to keep their child in school is influenced by merit-based or non-merit-based promotions. Results suggest that the enrollment decision is significantly influenced by whether learning has taken place, and that grade promotion that is uncorrelated with merit has a negligible impact on school continuation. 2012-06-04T15:04:47Z 2012-06-04T15:04:47Z 2008-09 http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2008/09/9881999/promotion-without-learning-effects-student-enrollment-dropout-behavior http://hdl.handle.net/10986/6974 English Policy Research Working Paper No. 4722 CC BY 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/ World Bank World Bank, Washington, DC Publications & Research :: Policy Research Working Paper Publications & Research South Asia Pakistan |