Refleksif dirinya: Satu analisis sintaksis
This article discusses noun phrase (NP) diriya which is known as reflexive in Malay language. However, this reflexive has an ambiguous reading in a sentence. This is because the NP dirinya can have a reference in a clause as well as outside a clause in the same sentence. As a result, this reflexi...
Main Author: | |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
Journal of Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities. Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia
2008
|
Online Access: | http://journalarticle.ukm.my/1573/ http://journalarticle.ukm.my/1573/ http://journalarticle.ukm.my/1573/1/fazal.pdf |
id |
ukm-1573 |
---|---|
recordtype |
eprints |
spelling |
ukm-15732016-12-14T06:29:49Z http://journalarticle.ukm.my/1573/ Refleksif dirinya: Satu analisis sintaksis Dr. Fazal Mohamed Mohamed Sultan, This article discusses noun phrase (NP) diriya which is known as reflexive in Malay language. However, this reflexive has an ambiguous reading in a sentence. This is because the NP dirinya can have a reference in a clause as well as outside a clause in the same sentence. As a result, this reflexive disobeyed Principle A. On the other hand, this type of reflexive occasionally is known as a long distance reflexive. Mashudi and Solakhiah (1997) had analysed this form of dirinya in a generative framework. They have claimed that the ambiguous reading of this reflexive dirinya was caused by the existence of [+reflexive] and [+pronominal] features which is generated by the NP dirinya at Sstructure. Even though, both of these language experts have argued very convincingly that the reason for the ambiguity of the NP dirinya was because of the different of features that existed on the NP but they didn’t explain how two readings could have co-existed at the same level in the syntax. Their suggestions to have two readings to operate at the same level will not be able to reach the explanatory adequacy of a grammar. This analysis too will not be able to explain sentences like these: Sayai percaya bahawa Salimj telah menembak dirinya*i/j/k. (I believe that Salim has shot himself) atau Salimj percaya bahawa sayai telah menembak dirinya*i/j/k.( Salim believe that I have shot himself/myself). Therefore, this paper will try to fill the gaps. This analysis claims that the reasons for the ambiguity is due to the features [+3] and [+pronominal] on the enclitic ‘-nya’ and the feature [+reflexive] on the form diri which operates at a different syntactic level. This means that the ambiguity reading on dirinya in a sentence is because at the D-structure the native speaker will have the pronominal reading and it continues to exist until the Sstructure. At the S-structure, the speaker will have reflexive reading. The existence of two readings at different levels will cause dirinya to have an ambiguity reading. This analysis will be argued using the Binding Theory which controls the distribution of NP in a sentence Journal of Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities. Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia 2008 Article PeerReviewed application/pdf en http://journalarticle.ukm.my/1573/1/fazal.pdf Dr. Fazal Mohamed Mohamed Sultan, (2008) Refleksif dirinya: Satu analisis sintaksis. e-BANGI: Jurnal Sains Sosial dan Kemanusiaan, 3 (1). p. 18. ISSN 1823-884x http://www.ukm.my/e-bangi/ |
repository_type |
Digital Repository |
institution_category |
Local University |
institution |
Universiti Kebangasaan Malaysia |
building |
UKM Institutional Repository |
collection |
Online Access |
language |
English |
description |
This article discusses noun phrase (NP) diriya which is known as reflexive in Malay
language. However, this reflexive has an ambiguous reading in a sentence. This is because
the NP dirinya can have a reference in a clause as well as outside a clause in the same
sentence. As a result, this reflexive disobeyed Principle A. On the other hand, this type of
reflexive occasionally is known as a long distance reflexive. Mashudi and Solakhiah
(1997) had analysed this form of dirinya in a generative framework. They have claimed
that the ambiguous reading of this reflexive dirinya was caused by the existence of
[+reflexive] and [+pronominal] features which is generated by the NP dirinya at Sstructure.
Even though, both of these language experts have argued very convincingly that
the reason for the ambiguity of the NP dirinya was because of the different of features that
existed on the NP but they didn’t explain how two readings could have co-existed at the
same level in the syntax. Their suggestions to have two readings to operate at the same
level will not be able to reach the explanatory adequacy of a grammar. This analysis too
will not be able to explain sentences like these: Sayai percaya bahawa Salimj telah
menembak dirinya*i/j/k. (I believe that Salim has shot himself) atau Salimj percaya bahawa
sayai telah menembak dirinya*i/j/k.( Salim believe that I have shot himself/myself).
Therefore, this paper will try to fill the gaps. This analysis claims that the reasons for the
ambiguity is due to the features [+3] and [+pronominal] on the enclitic ‘-nya’ and the
feature [+reflexive] on the form diri which operates at a different syntactic level. This
means that the ambiguity reading on dirinya in a sentence is because at the D-structure the
native speaker will have the pronominal reading and it continues to exist until the Sstructure.
At the S-structure, the speaker will have reflexive reading. The existence of two
readings at different levels will cause dirinya to have an ambiguity reading. This analysis
will be argued using the Binding Theory which controls the distribution of NP in a
sentence |
format |
Article |
author |
Dr. Fazal Mohamed Mohamed Sultan, |
spellingShingle |
Dr. Fazal Mohamed Mohamed Sultan, Refleksif dirinya: Satu analisis sintaksis |
author_facet |
Dr. Fazal Mohamed Mohamed Sultan, |
author_sort |
Dr. Fazal Mohamed Mohamed Sultan, |
title |
Refleksif dirinya: Satu analisis sintaksis |
title_short |
Refleksif dirinya: Satu analisis sintaksis |
title_full |
Refleksif dirinya: Satu analisis sintaksis |
title_fullStr |
Refleksif dirinya: Satu analisis sintaksis |
title_full_unstemmed |
Refleksif dirinya: Satu analisis sintaksis |
title_sort |
refleksif dirinya: satu analisis sintaksis |
publisher |
Journal of Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities. Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia |
publishDate |
2008 |
url |
http://journalarticle.ukm.my/1573/ http://journalarticle.ukm.my/1573/ http://journalarticle.ukm.my/1573/1/fazal.pdf |
first_indexed |
2023-09-18T19:33:44Z |
last_indexed |
2023-09-18T19:33:44Z |
_version_ |
1777405132118425600 |